Financing and Budgeting
Legal Considerations
Contractor Payment Guide: Before Or After Job Completion?

Contractor Payment Guide: Before Or After Job Completion?

Picture of the owner of Birkes BuildersDavid Birkes
Owner | General Contractor & Builder
Birkes Builders
Published On:
August 15, 2023
Last updated:
August 15, 2023
a large house with a lot of trees in front of it

Introduction: The Dance of Trust - Setting the Stage

The Contractual Tango: Teetering on the Tightrope of Trust

When it comes to home renovations, construction projects, or any other contractual work, the relationship between the contractor and client is a dance - a delicate waltz that teeters on the tightrope of trust. Each party, in their tuxedo or ballgown of expectations and obligations, must be perfectly in sync with their partner's steps for this dance to be successful. Yet too often this dance becomes a perilous seesaw act.

And why? All because we grapple with one contentious question that tips the balance: should you pay your contractor before or after they've completed their job?

Unveiling The Conundrum: The Million-Dollar Question

Should we pay upfront and risk our hard-earned cash falling into an abyss of unfulfilled promises? Or hold payment until completion, placing immense pressure on our contractor's shoulders?

It's a conundrum that bewilders many and has led countless well-intentioned individuals into pits of regret. This quandary isn't just an economic decision.

Nay! It is a test--a test of faith--a gamble on trustworthiness and integrity.

To whom do we tip our hats? The cautious cynics who clutch their purses tightly or those audacious optimists who dare to take that leap of faith?

Well then, let us take you through this convoluted maze where money trades hands across the wide gulf separating promise from fulfillment. Let's unravel together whether to pay your contractor before they've hammered in even one nail or only when they've packed up their tools for good.

Act I: Prepayment -- A Leap of Faith

Unchecked Trust: Deciphering the Enigma of Prepayment

Let's start by unraveling the mystery of prepayment. It's a simple concept, really, but one fraught with complications and potential pitfalls. When you pay a contractor upfront, it is not just an exchange of green bills - it's an investment in trust; a fragile bond that could either solidify into unshakeable mutual faith or shatter into a thousand shards of fraudulence.

Indeed, handing over your hard-earned money before any tangible work materializes? It's tantamount to jumping off a cliff blindfolded -- an act requiring both courage and perhaps even foolhardiness.

The Pros of Prepayment: An Unexpected Harmony

Cementing Bonds: How Prepayment Seals the Deal

Unpopular as this opinion may be, prepayment is not all gloom and doom! In certain scenarios, it can be akin to a melodious harmony echoing through the chaos.

It compels commitment -- there you are entrusting the contractor with your money and thereby sealing the deal. By paying them upfront, you've essentially put skin in the game!

The contractor now has less room to wiggle out or abandon ship midway because they have already accepted financial responsibility for your project. Thus sometimes all that prepayments do is ensure commitment!

Fueling Progression: How Material Acquisition Justifies Prepayments

Speaking more on this contentious issue - prepayments often grease the wheels for material acquisition which fuels your project. Construction work isn't pixie dust sprinkled work; materials are vital! Often these materials need to be purchased beforehand and guess what funds those purchases?

Your good old prepayments. The contractor hence becomes armed with necessary resources right from inception which prevents delays downline due to lack of materials.

The Cons of Prepayment: Discord in our Melody

When Contractors Disappear: The Dark Side Of Risk

Now let's talk about one possible grim consequence where our contractors transform into magicians performing disappearing acts with our money! While not all contractors are deceitful individuals waiting to dupe unsuspecting clients (and I'm not saying they are), it remains essential for consumers to assess whether their selected professional manifests any risk factors.

It requires little effort for one bad egg in this vast contracting universe to vanish completely once they have pocketed your hard-earned cash. Hence here we stand balancing ourselves on a razor's edge while considering prepayments.

The Pitfall Of Mediocrity : Craftsmanship Blinded By Money

Let's address another elephant in our room - Quality concerns stemming from early payments! Here goes my rant; why on earth would contractors strive for excellence when they've already pocketed their fee? There's no incentive left!

Having been paid full remuneration before lifting even a hammer or saw can lead some contractors down the path towards mediocre quality workmanship which surely none us want! Remember craftsmanship breeds from dedication rather than pacification using money.

Act II: Post-payment -- The Reward at the End

Decoding Post-payment: What's in It for You?

In my opinion, the concept of post-payment is truly a symphony for the ears of those who value their hard-earned coins. Yes, it is nothing less than a triumphant fanfare that announces one's financial safety and security.

It tells you, in no uncertain terms, that your pocket book will not be held hostage to a contractor who might or might not fulfill their obligations. But wait!

There's more. With post-payment, you are also afforded the luxury of assessing quality before making payment.

Isn't that marvelous? You can march through every room of your newly renovated home, inspecting each nook and cranny before deciding whether or not to release those funds.

Advantages of Post-payment: Sweet Notes in a Symphony

Quality Assurance - Holding High Standards Hostage The advantage of post-payment cannot be overstated when it comes to quality assurance.

Imagine this scenario: You've hired a contractor and paid him upfront only to find out later that he has done an atrocious job! But with post-payment at play, things will undoubtedly pan out differently.

This option holds your hard-earned money ransom against high-quality work from your contractor. Financial Security - Keeping Your Wallet Close

Financial security is another note that sweetens the symphony of post-payment benefits. Why would anyone want to take such risks by paying upfront?

It baffles me! If you pay after completion of the project, you are keeping yourself financially secure from potential scams or subpar performances.

Disadvantages of Post-payment : Hitting a Sour Note

Contractor Reluctance : Fear of Non-Payment Now let's talk about some possible sour notes in this symphony -- starting with potential reluctance from contractors themselves due to fear of nonpayment. Yes folks!

Not everyone out there is ready for this kind of trust-building exercise because they've been burned before by customers who did not fulfill their end of bargain! Delayed Completion : When Time Is Held Ransom

And then there's the nagging issue related to delayed completion when contractors may take an unnecessarily long time knowing they only get paid after work completes. Your dream renovation could drag on indefinitely while said contractor takes up other jobs on side thereby holding time itself for ransom.

Interlude: Legal Perspectives and Industry Standards

The Maze of Contractual Obligations: Navigating Deceptive Legal Waters

Now, let's talk about the beast in the room that people so often shy away from -- contractual obligations. The labyrinthian landscape of legal jargon and clauses can make even the most confident homeowner tremble.

However, it is this very beast that reigns supreme over any contractor-client relationship. Contracts stand as a monument to trust, but at the same time hold within them a minefield of potential disputes.

To clear the murky waters, one should understand that contracts are designed to protect both parties involved. It's not just a weapon for some slick contractor to rob you blind!

The contract lays out detailed conditions for payment - whether it is upfront or upon completion of work - and this serves as a legally binding rule book for your transaction. With a well-drafted contract, homeowners can guarantee their financial security while ensuring contractors are motivated enough to finish their job.

Bowing to the Conductor: Following Industry Norms

Then we have industry norms. Ah, those revered practices cast in stone by years of tradition and unspoken rules! A system that tells you to follow because 'that's what has always been done'.

But let me ask you - why should we blindly accept such dictates? Why not question these so-called norms when it comes to paying contractors?

If everyone followed age-old traditions without batting an eyelid, we'd still be living in caves! The industry norm postulates that prepayment provides contractors with necessary capital for materials and initial labor costs.

This has been accepted without question by many homeowners who end up falling prey to unscrupulous contractors who disappear once they get their hands on your hard-earned money! It's time we shook off this docile acceptance of traditional practices and instead opt for an arrangement more suited to our times -- partial payments or escrow services maybe?

Finale: Striking a Balance -- The Compromise Solution

A Pragmatic Ballet: Staged Payments

For all the discord and cacophony that tints the question of prepayment or post-payment, there is a harmonious middle ground -- staged payments. Like a symphony that meticulously weaves together diverse notes to create melody, staged payments marry the best of both worlds. This is not merely my robust opinion, but an echo of pragmatic wisdom from industry veterans.

Staged payments are essentially a series of smaller payments made at different stages of the work. It's akin to serving up your trust in bite-sized pieces rather than offering it as one grand feast.

The initial payment could cover material costs while subsequent ones can be contingently tied with milestones or phases. This ensures that your hard-earned money isn't entirely at risk and equally guarantees that contractors have a financial carrot dangling before them as incentive for quality craftsmanship and timely completion.

The Grandmaster Puppeteer: Escrow Services

If you're still jittery about slapping down wads of cash upfront or holding onto every last penny till the end, let me introduce you to another maestro in this dance -- escrow services. Much like a skilled puppeteer who masterfully orchestrates marionette movements from high above, escrow services act as third-party mediators between you - the client - and the contractor. Upon engaging an escrow service, both parties agree upon terms beforehand and monies are deposited into an escrow account controlled by this neutral entity.

Upon reaching agreed milestones, money is released from this account to pay your contractor. This maintains financial security for you while ensuring prompt payment for contractors upon job completion or during stages thereof.

Escrow services do charge for their orchestration skills but considering it provides peace-of-mind for both parties involved in our tumultuous dance of trust--the investment can be worth every penny! So next time when hiring a contractor consider these options before diving headlong into an unsecured prepayment or rigid post-payment agreement.

The Grand Finale: Bringing Down the Curtain on Payment Practices


In the labyrinthine game of contractor payments, one would be hard-pressed to stumble upon an unblemished answer. However, after delving into the intricacies of this topic, it seems abundantly clear that neither prepayment nor post-payment can claim to be a panacea for all the ills that plague this space.

Like every other transactional relationship, paying contractors is fraught with its own unique set of challenges and rewards. We've danced around the pros and cons of both prepayment and post-payment practices; we've waded through their legal implications; we've even taken a peek into industry norms.

We know now that leap-of-faith prepayments could tie us in knots while seemingly rewarding post-payments could leave us hanging in suspense. But there's no reason to despair or throw caution to the wind!

What then is our saving grace? Well, if you ask me - and you are - a well thought out compromise solution seems to be our best bet!

By embedding staged payments into contracts or through the cautious use of escrow services, we can indeed navigate these treacherous waters with relative ease. Let us not forget that every cloud has a silver lining!

Despite its complexities, properly managing contractor payments has several benefits up its sleeve. It cultivates trust and fosters mutual respect in business relationships, ensuring smoother project execution.

It also opens up avenues for more significant projects in future as contractors tend to prioritize clients who have a track record of prompt payments. In essence, pitting prepayment against post-payment may make for an exciting debate but it contributes little towards resolving real-world dilemmas.

Instead focus on finding middle ground where both parties feel secure & respected - therein lies your victory! Yes, paying contractors may seem like an intricate ballet but remember - every dance becomes more beautiful when partners move in harmony.

Share On:

Related Blogs